
Even more than on The Rising and Magic, music comes first on Working on a Dream
Working On A Dream aptly describes the contrasts of the album and Springsteen's entire musical persona. He has been from the start a romantic who understands that achieving dreams involves a struggle, a struggle that often overcomes those dreams (see Nebraska). As much as "Thunder Road" and "Born to Run" are anthems to chasing down the future, they're also anthems to escaping the present and the past, the "death trap" that "rips the bones off your back." In other words, achieving a dream takes work. On Working On A Dream, that dream is almost exclusively the work of love.
The album opens with "Outlaw Pete," an eight-minute narrative I described as Cinemascope Bruce the first time I heard it. "Elanor Rigby" strings introduce us to Pete and the musical sense of running that persists through most of the song. In a way, "Outlaw Pete" is an epic tall tale version of "Nebraska," a bad man on the run song, only this one starts out funny:
As the song progresses, it gets darker. Outlaw Pete awakes "from of vision of his own death" and rides west, where he marries a Navajo woman and lives a new life "on the res." Bounty Hunter Dan arrives and disrupts his quite life, reminding him that he's still who he was, Outlaw Pete. The song ends mysteriously and sadly with Pete perhaps plummeting off a cliff and his wife braiding a piece of his buckskin chaps in his hair and calling his name. Musically, the song covers as much ground as Pete himself, with strings and "Do do do dos," time changes and spooky western harmonica. It builds to an aching combined string, organ, and guitar finale over Springsteen's ever fainter refrain "Can you hear me?" It's kind of a crazy way to open album, but the song never grows tired even under the weight of all its mixed-up magic.He was born a little baby on the Appalachian Trail
At six months old he'd done three months in jail
He robbed a bank in his diapers and little bare baby feet
All he said was "Folks my name is Outlaw Pete"
I'm Outlaw Pete, I'm Outlaw Pete, can you hear me?
"My Lucky Day" and "Working on a Dream" quickly follow. Both are instantly singable, musical songs that lack a little in the lyrics. Here, Springsteen relies on abstractions rather than the concrete details of many of his best songs. In "My Lucky Day," he sings "In the room where fortune falls/On a day when chance is all." I suppose he could mean a casino, but that never becomes clear. In "Working on a Dream," he offers "Rain's pourin' down I swing my hammer/My hands are rough from working on a dream," but you don't ever get the sense he means a literal hammer. Nevertheless, the songs work because, as with many good songs, the music fills in what the lyrics leave out. In the case of "My Lucky Day," the song picks up where "Outlaw Pete" left off -- careening drums, a lot of guitars, rollicking piano and organ, a dominating bass line, and a big rock vocal. The passion of the music makes you believe that the singer's lover is his lucky day. "Working on a Dream" is a little more laid back but has some wonderful elements like the bassy piano notes near the end of the verses and Springsteen offering some of his moaning harmonies with himself. It also one odball moment, a whistling/baritone sax break that overcomes its oddness to become infuriatingly catchy. If ever Springsteen wrote a whistling song, this is it.
Next we reach the first of three pop hymns "Queen of the Supermarket." I like this song quite a bit, but it perplexes me. It tells a simple story of a lonley man in love with a cashier at the supermarket. He sees the supermarket itself in grand terms:
Given that vision of the supermarket, as Springsteen has said in interviews, there must be a queen, and for the singer, she works at the register on aisle two. I can read the song a few ways. One, he represents another lost, lonely character in the Springsteen oeuvre and would be at home on Nebraska. Two, it's an ironic song, a mock epic, and we shouldn't take him seriously, a stance Springsteen usually reserves for the wicked. Three, he's a lost, lonely character on the cusp of doing something about his troubles. I choose the third, though certain lyrics support the other takes ("With guidance from the gods above /At night I pray for the strength to tell the one I love/I love, I love, I love her so" is perhaps a little too grandiose). The building music supports an empathetic take on the character and a sense of not just longing but striving. The song begins quietly with piano and tinkling glockenspiel. As the singer physically makes his way through the supermarket and closer to the cashier, the music becomes stronger and brighter with guitars and drums, building up to the last verse. It grows softer again with the lines "As I lift my groceries into my cart\I turn back for a moment and catch a smile." Then it rises on the last line, Springsteen in as full a voice as he's ever used, "That blows this whole fucking place apart." Is it just the power of the smile that matters, or is the smile directed at him? I'm not sure, but following on the heels of "My Lucky Day" and "Working on a Dream" and in the context of an album about living in the moment, I think we're witnessing the moment before the moment.There's a wonderful world where all you desire
And everything you've longed for is at your fingertips
Where the bittersweet taste of life is at your lips
Where aisles and aisles of dreams await you
And the cool promise of ecstasy fills the air
Springsteen doesn't completely shed his penchant for dark songs on the album. "What Love Can Do" has a funky edginess that clashes with "Queen of the Supermarket" and the next song "This Life." The music centers on taut drumming, Springsteen's acoustic rhythm guitar, and some blistering harmonica and electric guitar. The lyrics recall Springsteen songs like "Cover Me," "Prove It All Night," and even "Thunder Road." Essentially, in a fallen world, love is the saving grace, and the singer wants to prove that to someone: "Here our memory lay corrupted and our city lay dry\Let me make this vow to you\Here where it's blood for blood and an eye for an eye\Let me show you what love can do." "What Love Can Do" is possibly the least interesting song on the album, but it plays a necessary role in between the brightness of "Queen of the Supermarket" and "This Life." Musically, it gives the audience a chance to breathe. Lyrically, it reminds them what the singers in the other songs want to or have overcome.
"This Life" wraps the thoughts of a formerly lonely man in lush Beach Boys harmonies and pop orchestrations that reinforce some of the cosmic images of the song. The singer tells his lover "At night at my telescope alone\This emptiness I've roamed\Searching for a home," and his focus on the night sky creates the central images of a the song: "stardust in your eyes," "the evening sky strikes sparks," "a million suns," "a blackness then the light of a million stars." All of these images serve as metaphors for her or her presence in his life. This man, who spent so much time looking beyond "this lonely planet," has found his home on this planet, in the neighborhood, in his car, in this woman, and he cherishes even one moment with her. Springsteen cements this concept in my favorite couplet on the album "I finger the hem of your dress/My universe at rest." This song starts big, and it gets bigger, soaring at the end with sets of harmonies bouncing off and blending with one another, then rising a little more on a Clarence Clemons sax solo. In way, it also forms a triptych with "Queen of the Supermarket" and "What Love Can Do." We move from yearning to wooing to an actual relationship.
Then for a song, Springsteen takes it all away. With its talk of betrayal and regret, the Chicago blues stomp "Good Eye" would have fit nicely on Tunnel of Love. Springsteen uses a technique he's used on his last couple tours, singing and playing harmonica through a microphone plugged into a guitar amplifier. It's not a new idea, but it sounds wild and frightening in his hands as the band zeroes in on the looping groove with electric guitars, electric piano, either a mandolin or a banjo, and some spooky harmonies. The title comes from the last line of each of the three verses "I had my good eye to the dark and my blind eye to the sun." In a strange way, the regret in this line describes the purpose of much of the album, to turn the good eye to the sun, the light. For all Springsteen's anthems, he's focused much of his energy on dark subject matter from "Born to Run" to "Born in the U.S.A." to much of Magic. On Working On A Dream, he doesn't turn a blind eye to that darkness, but he chooses to embrace the good in life.
In contrast, "Tomorrow Never Knows" is a gentle, mid-tempo country song that does turn its good eye to the sun. In this case, the sun means nature, togetherness, moments. The song doesn't completely ignore the darker aspects of life, but the singer has accepted not knowing the future and has decided to embrace the now. Springsteen sings, "You and me, we been standing here my dear\Waiting for our time to come\Where the green grass grows\Tomorrow never knows." For a man who's often written about discontent and longing, this marks a bit of a change and a respite before the darkest song on the album.
"The thing is based around its retaining tension," Springsteen tells members of the E Street Band on the DVD that accompanies the deluxe edition of Working On A Dream. He's talking about "Life Itself," one of Springsteen's most unique songs. The band does maintain its tension in a psychedelic guitars and organ swirl around drums, bass, and Springsteen's deliberate vocals. Lines of electric twelve-string guitar spark and scatter between the choruses and verses, and Nils Lofgren plays a backwards guitar solo. Again, the music bolsters lyrics that aren't always its equal. The song opens with "We met down in the valley where the wine of love and destruction flowed\There in the curve of darkness where the flowers of temptation grows." I don't know where this valley exists, but I don't want to go there. The singer meets a woman there who feels as "good as life itself." In the second verse, he could be addressing the same person or someone else, someone whose life has gone awry. It's all a little vague, but the last and powerful verse suggests a narrative of a relationship from a beginning to its failure:
Why do the things that we treasure most, slip away in timeThis verse also represents one of the central themes in all of Springsteen's work, the crippling power of isolation and its causes. It also reinforces the idea of working on the dream of love because it can slip away.
Till to the music we grow deaf, to God's beauty blind
Why do the things that connect us slowly pull us apart?
Till we fall away in our own darkness, a stranger to our own hearts
And life itself
"Kingdom of Days," the final pop hymn, confronts the specters of time and mortality not with fear but with love. While the music starts big and grows with swelling strings and Springsteen's fullest voice yet, the lyrics remain grounded. When he's with his lover, time means nothing to the singer, and he finds joy in the small details of a life together. In a way, many of the lyrics call back to "You're Missing" from The Rising. There details like shirts, shoes, coffee cups, and jackets remind the singer of a dead spouse. In "Kingdom of Days," similar details serve as talismans against time, age, and death:
They also "laugh beneath the covers and count the wrinkles and the grays." In the last chorus, he exhorts her (and maybe the audience) to "Sing away, sing away." Springsteen's voice has never sounded bigger than in this last verse and chorus. It sounds so big, in fact, that some of the extra musical richness seems excessive, especially a string flourish right before the final verse, but making the song a lush ballad works. In contrast to the musically spare "You're Missing," which was an elegy for the past and things lost, "Kingdom of Days" is a celebration of the now and things gained.I watch the sun as it rises and sets
I watch the moon trace its arc with no regrets
My jacket around your shoulders, the falling leaves
The wet grass on our backs as the autumn breeze drifts through the trees
"Surprise, Surprise" is also a celbration and quite simply the happiest song Springsteen's released. Essentially, the singer offers a birthday wish for happiness and health. Once again, for me, the music is the story. Jangling guitars and an early Bristish Invasion beat open the song. The bright guitars sound like The Byrds, but their interplay reminds me of the guitars on songs like "She Said, She Said" and "Your Bird Can Sing" from The Beatles' Revolver. The interesting minor chords in what I'll call the verses conjure early Beatles songs, as do the handclaps*, though they accompany a bridge that sounds like an uptempo "All You Need Is Love." Absolutely infectious.
The album officially ends with "The Last Carnival," a somber good-bye to E Street Band keyboardist Danny Federici. Acoustic guitar, calliope-like accordion (Federici's son Jason), and some harmonies make up the music. The lyrics call back to "Wild Billy's Circus Story" from Springsteen's second album The Wild, the Innocent, and the E Street Shuffle. In that song, a boy named Billy joined the circus. In "The Last Carnival," Billy's gone:
We won't be dancing together on the high wireThe circus/carnival folk will "be riding the train without you tonight...A million stars shining above us like every soul livin' and dead\Has been gathered together by a God to sing a hymn over your bones." The song ends with haunting, almost spooky harmonies, voices piled on top of one another, though Patti Scialfa's pierces through them. Good-bye, "Phantom" Dan.
Facing the lions with you at my side anymore
We won't be breathin' the smoke and the fire
On the midway
Hangin' from the trapeze my wrists waitin' for your wrists
Two daredevils high up on the wall of death
You throwin' the knife that lands inches from my heart
The bonus track "The Wrestler" from the movie of the same name fits nicely with Springsteen's other movie songs "Streets of Philadelphia," "Missing," and "Dead Man Walkin'." As in those songs, Springsteen takes on the voice of the movie's protagonist, in this case an aging wrestler. He plays all the instruments, too -- acoustic guitar, piano, a smattering of drums. The wrestler compares himself to a one trick pony, a one legged dog, and a one armed man. He sees his own failures, but he finds solace and pride in his work, even if it has created his situation: "I always leave with less than I had before...but I can make you smile when the blood it hits the floor\Tell me friend can you ask for anything more."
Like The Rising and maybe even Darkness On the Edge of Town, Working On A Dream feels like a flawed masterpiece. As powerful as The Rising is, it gets weighed down by too many songs and a few of the same lyrical missteps as Working On A Dream. Darkness suffers from music and a mix that doesn't always rise to the occasion, though the live versions do (something Springsteen has commented on before). Music isn't the problem on Working On A Dream. Springsteen, The E Street Band, and producer Brendan O'Brien create a fascinating musical blend, melding multiple influences into a powerful sound. At times, the lyrics don't carry their full weight and the music has to bear more, but there the album succeeds. What more can I say than, Bruce, "Sing away, sing away, sing away"?
*One time, a friend and I heard John Cafferty and the Beaver Brown Band's "On the Dark Side" from Eddie and the Cruisers. The first half of the song sounds like, to be charitable, a Springsteen homage, but then it shifts gears with handclaps and a basic guitar riff. I told my friend it had just gone from a Springsteen song to a Mellencamp song. He said, "Really?" As far as I can remember, "Surprise, Surprise" marks the first appearance of handclaps on a Springsteen song, or at least one on an album. The outtake "Without You" does feature some.





